Boring Guardian summary
Kelly still smelly
Coroner could hold new Kelly inquest, Simon Jeffery, Guardian, Thursday January 22, 2004
A coroner is considering opening a fresh inquest into the death of David Kelly after it emerged that Lord Hutton was not passed all the information that police had collected about the weapons expert's apparent suicide.
BBC self flagelation in: Panoramic display of fearless self-loathing over Kelly/Hutton Did anyone see this? I thought it was fascinating... strange timing though.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Tony Blair fielding questions from the public over tuition fees on line.... his answers are in the Guardian
Question from Joss Garman:
Why do you feel that the £1.5bn pounds spent annually on Trident, is better spent on weapons of mass destruction, than on my education and the education of others my age?
TB: I really don't feel this is a comparison we can make. We have a lot of competing demands right across public spending, and we need to balance all of them. Proper defence is essential for our national security.
.... however we can't build our own bloody nukes, missiles, planes etc. because we have a chronic shortage of scientists. No one ever tries to attack us, and when they do, we wont be able to defend ourselves with bombs and tanks, it will probably be more of a T.W.A.T. situation, requiring some "intellegence" which is remarkably thin on the ground nowadays. prime minister.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Shocking, but predictable... maybe it's also essential for national security
Who gives wealthy men £1,000 a day each to subsidise their farms? - the taxpayer
Charlotte Denny, Larry Elliott and Charlotte Moore, Thursday January 22, 2004, The Guardian
The Duke of Westminster, Britain's richest man, receives a daily handout from the taxpayer of £1,000 under a welfare system for some of the country's biggest landowners provided through Europe's lavish farm subsidy regime.
... Guardian campaign against the Countryside Alliance, notice the use of Tabloid style sensationalism: "Europe's lavish farm subsidy regime" like asylum seeker rants by the Daily Mail
better point though
22.1.04
21.1.04
Tuition fees 'fairest way' to fund universities, says OECD
Donald MacLeod... in the guardian
Tuesday January 20, 2004
Tony Blair and his ministers today received international backing for their efforts to sell top-up fees to sceptical backbench MPs and the public.
The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), which monitors all developed countries, strongly endorsed the government's higher education plans as "essential" to revitalise British universities and a "role model" for other European countries. Its 2004 UK economic survey argued that the scheme would help all students, including those from poorer backgrounds, and was the fairest way to fund universities.
OECD, Economic Survey - United Kingdom 2004 includes tuition fees report
Judicial Review: 'Kidnapped' Protestors Challenge Police
features, 15.01.2004 09:41 From indymedia, pictures and film also available on this link.
Friday 16th Jan: A Judicial Review at the High Court yesterday began proceedings considering the lawfulness of the police actions last March when around 150 anti-war campaigners were 'coachnapped' - stopped and searched for almost two hours on their way to demonstration at RAF Fairford, then forcibly returned to London under police escort (pics). As the protestors put signs in the coach windows saying "Help We've Been Kidnapped" "Call the Media" and "Denied The Right To Protest The War", the police closed the motorway behind the coaches while police motorcycle outriders blocked motorway exits.
The campaigners claimed the police overstepped their powers and furthermore that they breached articles of the European Convention on Human Rights, guaranteeing freedom from arbitrary detention, the freedom of speech and assembly, and respect for physical and psychological integrity.
Police statements revealed that at 10.45am an order was issued by Chief Superintendent Lambert to stop and search the coaches including instructions for the coaches to be turned around and escorted non-stop back to London if any 'dangerous items' or items likely to be used to conceal identity were found. It is this order that will now be scrutinised. Michael Fordham acting on behalf of the protestors said the police were within their powers to seize certain items, and that they even possibly had the right to detain certain individuals under public order and common laws, but they overstepped the law and infringed both common law and human rights law, by the blanket nature of their action (despite intelligence notes showing that the police were aware that the coach passengers were made up of individuals and members of various groups) and the way evidence was used in an attempt to justify this.
The case continues today at the High Court and a decision is expected from Lord Justice May and Mr Justice Harrisonin in around three weeks time.
Donald MacLeod... in the guardian
Tuesday January 20, 2004
Tony Blair and his ministers today received international backing for their efforts to sell top-up fees to sceptical backbench MPs and the public.
The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), which monitors all developed countries, strongly endorsed the government's higher education plans as "essential" to revitalise British universities and a "role model" for other European countries. Its 2004 UK economic survey argued that the scheme would help all students, including those from poorer backgrounds, and was the fairest way to fund universities.
OECD, Economic Survey - United Kingdom 2004 includes tuition fees report
Judicial Review: 'Kidnapped' Protestors Challenge Police
features, 15.01.2004 09:41 From indymedia, pictures and film also available on this link.
Friday 16th Jan: A Judicial Review at the High Court yesterday began proceedings considering the lawfulness of the police actions last March when around 150 anti-war campaigners were 'coachnapped' - stopped and searched for almost two hours on their way to demonstration at RAF Fairford, then forcibly returned to London under police escort (pics). As the protestors put signs in the coach windows saying "Help We've Been Kidnapped" "Call the Media" and "Denied The Right To Protest The War", the police closed the motorway behind the coaches while police motorcycle outriders blocked motorway exits.
The campaigners claimed the police overstepped their powers and furthermore that they breached articles of the European Convention on Human Rights, guaranteeing freedom from arbitrary detention, the freedom of speech and assembly, and respect for physical and psychological integrity.
Police statements revealed that at 10.45am an order was issued by Chief Superintendent Lambert to stop and search the coaches including instructions for the coaches to be turned around and escorted non-stop back to London if any 'dangerous items' or items likely to be used to conceal identity were found. It is this order that will now be scrutinised. Michael Fordham acting on behalf of the protestors said the police were within their powers to seize certain items, and that they even possibly had the right to detain certain individuals under public order and common laws, but they overstepped the law and infringed both common law and human rights law, by the blanket nature of their action (despite intelligence notes showing that the police were aware that the coach passengers were made up of individuals and members of various groups) and the way evidence was used in an attempt to justify this.
The case continues today at the High Court and a decision is expected from Lord Justice May and Mr Justice Harrisonin in around three weeks time.
*As any economist will tell you markets only benefit you to the extent to which you bring something to the table; they don't produce equitable outcomes from inequitable beginnings - au contraire as you won't need an economist to tell you. The freedom on offer is accurately described as freedom in respect of buying and selling things, and not the freedom to act which is (if you think about it) a predicate of the word freedom, used in an unqualified sense. Herein lies the grammatical conceit of the discourse! So, whilst you remain "free" to sell your labour power (i.e. if you're in the 99% apart from us who don't have anything else to sell!) at exactly the same time you are also compelled to rent yourself in order to survive. In other words "choice" means the freedom to choose to starve if you so wish. Choices made under coercion = duress, in turn, grounds, of course, for mitigation in a court of law. So...
*Re: fucking in the streets
Occured to me in shower this morning that it's somewhat odd, and on reflection somewhat revealing, that philosophy is seen as arcane and irrelevant. Doubting things, questioning, inquiring, unconstrained speculating on alternatives etc are essential techniques for knowledge creation - as in the recognition that such "knowledge" is simply a working hypothesis for the time being, to serve some end and not something substantive the conclusions of which should been seen as justifying various crimes (e.g. boiling your "infidel" enemy/letting "inefficient" brownies starve - delete as ideology demands).
So, in a healthy society there wouldn't be philosophers there would just be people engaged in tasks with these facts in mind. Instead we have people operating within a ideological conceit which is possible only to the extent to which the managers (you and i) don't think to raise certain questions. In the meantime philosophy remains an isolated and irrelevant task, for the usual reasons (doesn't fulfill role within the "discourse of legitimation").
*Pleased with Lilya review, I had read it at the time and made note to see (although unless you live in central london or bourgeoise ghetto, e.g. Brighton, Bath, Cambridge) you'll only find endless screens showing the bourne identity or some other shit. Why not forward review to peter "five star" bradshaw? Why not mention that giving films/plays/books stars out of five is fucking stupid and demeaning too!
*Re: fucking in the streets
Occured to me in shower this morning that it's somewhat odd, and on reflection somewhat revealing, that philosophy is seen as arcane and irrelevant. Doubting things, questioning, inquiring, unconstrained speculating on alternatives etc are essential techniques for knowledge creation - as in the recognition that such "knowledge" is simply a working hypothesis for the time being, to serve some end and not something substantive the conclusions of which should been seen as justifying various crimes (e.g. boiling your "infidel" enemy/letting "inefficient" brownies starve - delete as ideology demands).
So, in a healthy society there wouldn't be philosophers there would just be people engaged in tasks with these facts in mind. Instead we have people operating within a ideological conceit which is possible only to the extent to which the managers (you and i) don't think to raise certain questions. In the meantime philosophy remains an isolated and irrelevant task, for the usual reasons (doesn't fulfill role within the "discourse of legitimation").
*Pleased with Lilya review, I had read it at the time and made note to see (although unless you live in central london or bourgeoise ghetto, e.g. Brighton, Bath, Cambridge) you'll only find endless screens showing the bourne identity or some other shit. Why not forward review to peter "five star" bradshaw? Why not mention that giving films/plays/books stars out of five is fucking stupid and demeaning too!
no offence taken mike... don't worry, the debate is genuine and a good one.
you are right we offer a helping hand and take a step forward, whilst causing the problem in the first place by taking three steps backwards. but it is not bad to try and help those who are suffering now rather than always be waiting for the miraculous revolution, which probably wont come before we implode anyway. I do think we can work on both projects at once, working to overthrow the evil empire, whilst being nice and helping where you can along the way. we must not be naive indeed, but neither must we be paralysed by cynicism.
the 10 to 15 years information applies to legals as not much is, or can be known exactly about illegals. It is recieved wisdom in migration studies circles but applies to the US in the twentieth century. recent studies have contradicted this, as family reunification has become more prevalent than work migration and families aren't good for economic statistics. Immigrants (legal) also apparently contribute more in taxes than they claim in social security, although this too may be changed by family reunification... see my essay on the inquiry
the illegals point is certainly true: “those who own capital can make a living by using that capital almost anywhere in the world; however, those who do not own capital must make a living by selling their labour power ... only in ‘their’ country” (Fielding, 1993:41, cited in Black 1996:72).
you are right we offer a helping hand and take a step forward, whilst causing the problem in the first place by taking three steps backwards. but it is not bad to try and help those who are suffering now rather than always be waiting for the miraculous revolution, which probably wont come before we implode anyway. I do think we can work on both projects at once, working to overthrow the evil empire, whilst being nice and helping where you can along the way. we must not be naive indeed, but neither must we be paralysed by cynicism.
the 10 to 15 years information applies to legals as not much is, or can be known exactly about illegals. It is recieved wisdom in migration studies circles but applies to the US in the twentieth century. recent studies have contradicted this, as family reunification has become more prevalent than work migration and families aren't good for economic statistics. Immigrants (legal) also apparently contribute more in taxes than they claim in social security, although this too may be changed by family reunification... see my essay on the inquiry
the illegals point is certainly true: “those who own capital can make a living by using that capital almost anywhere in the world; however, those who do not own capital must make a living by selling their labour power ... only in ‘their’ country” (Fielding, 1993:41, cited in Black 1996:72).
"It is an uncompromisingly bleak, devastatingly powerful study of Lilya (Oksana Akinshina), a poverty-stricken teenage girl abandoned in a crumbling Russian town when her mother leaves, apparently for the United States, with a man she has met through a dating agency - and refuses to take her with them. In her wretchedness, Lilya finds a friend in a lonely 11-year-old boy, Volodya (Artyom Bogucharsky), but then precisely duplicates her mother's betrayal when she meets a smooth-talking young guy who says he can take her away to Sweden.
But then Moodysson, with a demonic showman's flourish, raises the curtain on the second act in Lilya's life. On arriving in Sweden she finds that the promised job does not exist. It was all a trick and Lilya is imprisoned and forced into prostitution - repeatedly raped, day after day after day, in ways that Moodysson pitilessly shows us from her perspective. And in a flash of delirious despair we can sense what is passing through Lilya's own mind: what has happened to her mother? Was the US she was promised an illusion also? And does Lilya somehow deserve what has happened for deserting Volodya? It is the biggest delusion, the strangest fear, and the worst horror of all.
This is certainly an extravagantly cruel movie: really cruel in a way that I have hardly experienced in any other film - but compelling as well. Forced prostitution is a horrible reality linking the pauperised post-Soviet states and the sex industry in the moneyed west. (Here I must raise a caveat. The Russian critic Alexander Kan tells me that the Russian dialogue sometimes sounds stilted, possibly from being unsatisfactorily translated from Swedish. I admit I can't judge this.)" [what's this? caveat? what's a caveat? why change topic just as you were getting to some sort of point?!]
quality of review shockingly low by the way. observer review even worse.. maybe due to this:
"The recent films released here about the illegals have been clearly shaped by liberal, decent concern. Moodysson's seems to me to be fiercer and more ambiguous than this."
to continue, or rather: start where mr. guardian stops [caveat? why doesnt he follow through on sentence (a)? here's a fucking caveat:]
let me rephrase: fiercer and more ambiguous than liberal and decent concern? beyond liberal or beyond decent?
this isnt a docusoap, its realistic fiction, that's why it hurts so fucking much. as it wasnt harry tosspott (mild-hearted asexual airey-fairey fantasy world bullshit), there were only three people in the audience. one girl ran out crying histerically, spilling popcorn all over the place. i found this film deeply involving emotionally. although there is a bit of a post-modern christian theme (lilya's friend reappears with angel-wings in her dream, she is carrying around an icon portraying orthodox saints which is meant to symbolise hope i suppose), this film is soldidly rooted in the dire circumstance of child prostitution and sex slavery.
although moodyson does stylise along clear moral lines to some extent there was no element of the "promised job- then held in cellar" deal which i hadnt read about in (mainstream journalistic) reports regarding the german meat trade for instance (on offer: children, kidneys). the dirty old mincers desperately clinging on to, sweating on, puberscent youth, vs the innocence of a young girl who is first forced to sell herself as she has been abandoned by her mother, then later sold for rape to mentally ill first world whiteys- it really is trivial information minus that silk lining!
the reviewer is correct in saying that moodyson knows "no pity" in terms of visuals. but why should we not get to see a little bit of that ugly everyday truth? "a vivisectional experiment in horror and despair"- that's exaclty what makes it so good you liberal-half-heart-wishi-washi twat! make the sex a bit prettier, the alienated rich paedophiles a bit younger, presto youve got fucking "Lolita" all over again! why should we not be reduced to tears for once? if you want smile + forget yourself flick on that superstars programme!
this film reflects on the neo-imperial gradient of wealth and the very real material consequences of our continuing acceptance of this contrast. human flesh/blood/spirit is of differential value depending on the geographical zone one happens to be geworfen into. if you're low-priority meat, vom schicksal gefickt [ok this is v crude heidegger] there's not even any point to praying/hoping for a future worth living.
have a nice day, enjoy your luxurious lifestyles, thanks god we're free to do as we're told- more snickers, more coke, put harry tosspott on!
the director lukas moodysson has also got a film on the gothenburg protests out, and appears to be working on a big-brotheresque piece.
20.1.04
dear fellow lovers of the (/a?) future
the monkey takes pride in its noise. this is perfectly normal and to be expected. i'd assert that this is one of the faulty heuristics of a conditio humana that has made progress in free thought, and hence historical development, impossible at times. to reconciliate contradicting views it seems necessary to dissociate one's ego from the message voiced and attempt to find some sort of common ground where communication is possible. this must not entail harmonious humming.
as i am as prone to this as anyone else i'd like to excuse the lack of clarity in my post below. our difficulties with discussing such issues do arise due to our geworfensein [excuse heideggerian speak]. the oppressor faces a much tougher existential quest in having to liberate himself from the double-speak and double-think as freire quite sexily put it back in the sixties. we are now of course much more heavily alienated, with the current generation literally growing up in some sort of multimedial, masturbatory fantasy-world. the asexual [innocent] nature of hero of our age harry tosser for instance is of course a different [if equally exciting!] topic. the whitey is responsible, not just in the negative sense, but also, positively, in "having the time and access to capital (power) necessary" [NC] i.e. should be doing something proper.
if you are then born into the minority of the opulent, priviledged to any information at all, you will quickly be facing the fact that you are essentially satan's spawn [in a post-christian, hicksian sense please!] and that your luxurious lifestyle finds its economic base in brownies dying face down in the mud. having grown accustomed to an excessively pampered lifestyle [i'm speaking for myself here, feel free to apply to your own CV] and seeing a glimpse of this, maybe through the use of hallucinogens, third world travel, chatting to "dishi-washa", the first task at hand: facilitate breaking down the supposed rigidity of institutional constructs, authoritarian structures, etc implanted in our heads, i.e. generally ridding the cognitive machinery of any belief in the ahistorical nature of the wording and grammar that legitimises that tasty [oh so tasty!] status quo with a silk lining.
such softening of mental constructs is the first step to not becoming one of a new generation of satan's little helpers contributing to the reproduction of material realities. anti-consumerism is so widespread in germany that there are even pop-stars on mtv germany advocating it and in fact there's a corresponding marketing clique going for the "half-hearted anti-dollar". the next step is to develop a negative dialectic to deconstruct reformist language. a critique of migration studies does not mean that there shouldnt be migration studies, just as much as finklestein's critique of the holocaust industry doesnt mean the jews didnt suffer and there shouldnt be information about it. the migration issue is actually a beautiful case for this sort of critique.
below i was going for a certain type of systemic analysis which i will try and outline systematically now. let me start by assuring you that i strongly believe that everybody needs to know about the situation of "illegals" in the first world. there's a form of liberal-left discourse around migrant's human rights etc. at the paris social forum for instance, the sans papiers were represented in massive numbers. they are organised in varying systems of direct democracy where only sans papiers are allowed to vote on aspects of the evolving organisations within the community. whiteys are allowed to help but they can of course not vote and never be part of these transitory forms.
now the easiest case for a political economy of migrant workers is in fact the us. i will not go into a history of the promised land and the people who lived there before the whitey pattern of inhabiting geographical space was applied- they are also amongst the face down in the mud section. to be as brief as possible there are lots of brownies in the u.s. who "technically" shouldnt be there but they run the bottom end of the so-called service economy. due to their questionable status institutional norms do not apply to them. there have been a number of liberal-left sociological studies indicating that black-market manual labourers do not enjoy access to "human rights" or indeed any part of the civil rights apparatus as they stand to be kicked out of "paradise" if they complain [thoynbee or whatever in the uk, similarly some woman in the u.s.].
wages may or may not be paid, and if the whitey boss decides to "have a crack" with the mexican cleaner he may do so as she has noone to complain to. benji says, immigrants "may aspire to be as rich as us and in the US their earnings usually overtake those of native born citizens in 10-15 years". i am in very very deep doubts about that proposition. to my mind illegals are the slaves of the modern period of economic imperialism, and, much as in the greek city states [model for our sys]: either youre a citizen, and its hanging out at the forum, bienvenidos to freedom and future, or you aint. in which case "inglan", which looked so sexy from the other side of the ocean, will suddenly turn out to be "a bitch".
as i was taught at sussex university [benji?] there have been "two periods of globalisation", one before WWI, one very recently. that is the most "critical" version of globalisation discourse there is. it is commonly forgotten that [continental european] border controls were only instituted after WWI. The modern nation-state was transformed during the fascist period and strongly resembles the totalitarian state developed during that period. and it remains that way. for good reason. the international gradient of wealth is regulated by "free market" theory. as critics of this theory have pointed out, free movement of capital will have a disastrous effect on living conditions for those at the receiving end of political power structures if there is no free movement of labour [-> competition of nation-states, speculation of capital, this is gramscian international political economy- excellent material. if you havent..].
this applies to NAFTA or the Eastern European Extension ["sponsored by Volkswagen"]- there will be a transition period of a few years where people may not cross freely. the difference in living and working conditions is maintained by reference to the romantic-reactionary nation-state model, which is, in its current form, a remnant of colonial imperialism and fascism. note that the bits re: slavery above put the illegal migrant at a very special position in the global economy, being both victim and enabler of pyramid-building at the national as well as the international level.
the minimal influx of migrants limits economic growth. germany is actually facing a huge disaster in terms of ageing population and a picture of "economic collapse by 2020" is being projected by pessimist economists [this is not to be taken too seriously as it is also part of an ideology of neo-liberal "reform" by the local tonys] if immigration is not increased to a couple of 100K a year. the german golden years of capitalism in the 50s and 60s were driven by a huge influx of workers which were actively recruited and sourced from different mediterranean countries to allow for the huge keynesian project of economic expanionism.
pyramid-building is not sensible in economic terms. low inflation, high interest, stable economies with minimal economic growth are best for the opulent minority who are hoarding cash and material value and worst for those living on wages. the influx of migrants is minimal and the disproportional noise ["commentary"] in the popular press is strongly ideological in nature. any analysis [consult left-liberal newspaper at hand] that does not take into account at least some of the [important] functional structures above will not get anywhere. political refugees coming from "failed states" (neo-colonial receiving end) are excluded from first world econ as "economic migrants" are- the science of creating and maintaining artifical barriers does not allow for exemptions.
the sad news is: going for "new, sensible immigration policy" is like advocating the re-introduction of keynesian economics: yes, it would help as far as any reform may. As marcuse says [196?, my translation + rough quote from memory] "reforms, anything that humanises the face of capitalism, can and must be tried. but there will always be a point when the reformist policy contradicts the pillar of the capitalist system, the principle of profit [or accelerated accumulation of capital]. Once this is breached, the question arises-- is revolution possible?"
far from wanting to criticise the proponent of any reformist stance, au contraire, my deepest respect and love to any vegetarian, fellow H&M purist, nudist, hedonist, gay pride, christian liberation theologist, long-hair, or whatever: it was the flawed discourse i was castigating. the rigity of a grammar that makes it all but impossible to express where its at. the self-censorship. the emotional frigidity. we must not be naive. i am sure that oxfam helps, that there are a lot of people "doing their best" on their ample allowances and london lifestyles, that they pull a number of brownies out of the dirt theyre in even..
if everything is thus connected to everything, there is one systemic totality, one functional rationale, with a vicious material reality to it [critical theoretical- in difference to marx, ?berbau is seen to be integral part of system], what is to be done?
it is possible to arrive at this question of questions from any theoretical starting point, whether it be a political economy of human rights, anti-psychiatry, radical ecology [primitivism], feminism, black power... these are all monkey attempts to understand own power. the question has not been asked properly, if there isnt some sort of resulting praxis!
who will be the first to have a cheeky crack at a radically new aesthetic in the new century? since those twisted romantics [nazis] fucked everything up, with the french intellectual promoting the continuation of said neo-romantic quest in true service to the lie, pillar to the grand gradients, there has been nothing. once creativity is unleashed, strong enough for subcutaneous realisation that "life is only a dream" etc, once the monkey-subject learns to realise itself:
again, marcuse: "we cannot know what the society of the future would look like, as we are unfree, and thus not able how a free subject would determine its mode of existence". it can only be found out in constant stuggle with the (imagined) rigidity of grammar, the (bullshit) ahistoricity claims to authoritarian language, overcoming the lack of belief in human action, fear of freedom... "there is no such thing as the revolutionary subject"- consciousness emerges in opposition to inertia, i.e. elements obstructing the process [negative dialectic]-
there will be fucking in the streets.
x
the monkey takes pride in its noise. this is perfectly normal and to be expected. i'd assert that this is one of the faulty heuristics of a conditio humana that has made progress in free thought, and hence historical development, impossible at times. to reconciliate contradicting views it seems necessary to dissociate one's ego from the message voiced and attempt to find some sort of common ground where communication is possible. this must not entail harmonious humming.
as i am as prone to this as anyone else i'd like to excuse the lack of clarity in my post below. our difficulties with discussing such issues do arise due to our geworfensein [excuse heideggerian speak]. the oppressor faces a much tougher existential quest in having to liberate himself from the double-speak and double-think as freire quite sexily put it back in the sixties. we are now of course much more heavily alienated, with the current generation literally growing up in some sort of multimedial, masturbatory fantasy-world. the asexual [innocent] nature of hero of our age harry tosser for instance is of course a different [if equally exciting!] topic. the whitey is responsible, not just in the negative sense, but also, positively, in "having the time and access to capital (power) necessary" [NC] i.e. should be doing something proper.
if you are then born into the minority of the opulent, priviledged to any information at all, you will quickly be facing the fact that you are essentially satan's spawn [in a post-christian, hicksian sense please!] and that your luxurious lifestyle finds its economic base in brownies dying face down in the mud. having grown accustomed to an excessively pampered lifestyle [i'm speaking for myself here, feel free to apply to your own CV] and seeing a glimpse of this, maybe through the use of hallucinogens, third world travel, chatting to "dishi-washa", the first task at hand: facilitate breaking down the supposed rigidity of institutional constructs, authoritarian structures, etc implanted in our heads, i.e. generally ridding the cognitive machinery of any belief in the ahistorical nature of the wording and grammar that legitimises that tasty [oh so tasty!] status quo with a silk lining.
such softening of mental constructs is the first step to not becoming one of a new generation of satan's little helpers contributing to the reproduction of material realities. anti-consumerism is so widespread in germany that there are even pop-stars on mtv germany advocating it and in fact there's a corresponding marketing clique going for the "half-hearted anti-dollar". the next step is to develop a negative dialectic to deconstruct reformist language. a critique of migration studies does not mean that there shouldnt be migration studies, just as much as finklestein's critique of the holocaust industry doesnt mean the jews didnt suffer and there shouldnt be information about it. the migration issue is actually a beautiful case for this sort of critique.
below i was going for a certain type of systemic analysis which i will try and outline systematically now. let me start by assuring you that i strongly believe that everybody needs to know about the situation of "illegals" in the first world. there's a form of liberal-left discourse around migrant's human rights etc. at the paris social forum for instance, the sans papiers were represented in massive numbers. they are organised in varying systems of direct democracy where only sans papiers are allowed to vote on aspects of the evolving organisations within the community. whiteys are allowed to help but they can of course not vote and never be part of these transitory forms.
now the easiest case for a political economy of migrant workers is in fact the us. i will not go into a history of the promised land and the people who lived there before the whitey pattern of inhabiting geographical space was applied- they are also amongst the face down in the mud section. to be as brief as possible there are lots of brownies in the u.s. who "technically" shouldnt be there but they run the bottom end of the so-called service economy. due to their questionable status institutional norms do not apply to them. there have been a number of liberal-left sociological studies indicating that black-market manual labourers do not enjoy access to "human rights" or indeed any part of the civil rights apparatus as they stand to be kicked out of "paradise" if they complain [thoynbee or whatever in the uk, similarly some woman in the u.s.].
wages may or may not be paid, and if the whitey boss decides to "have a crack" with the mexican cleaner he may do so as she has noone to complain to. benji says, immigrants "may aspire to be as rich as us and in the US their earnings usually overtake those of native born citizens in 10-15 years". i am in very very deep doubts about that proposition. to my mind illegals are the slaves of the modern period of economic imperialism, and, much as in the greek city states [model for our sys]: either youre a citizen, and its hanging out at the forum, bienvenidos to freedom and future, or you aint. in which case "inglan", which looked so sexy from the other side of the ocean, will suddenly turn out to be "a bitch".
as i was taught at sussex university [benji?] there have been "two periods of globalisation", one before WWI, one very recently. that is the most "critical" version of globalisation discourse there is. it is commonly forgotten that [continental european] border controls were only instituted after WWI. The modern nation-state was transformed during the fascist period and strongly resembles the totalitarian state developed during that period. and it remains that way. for good reason. the international gradient of wealth is regulated by "free market" theory. as critics of this theory have pointed out, free movement of capital will have a disastrous effect on living conditions for those at the receiving end of political power structures if there is no free movement of labour [-> competition of nation-states, speculation of capital, this is gramscian international political economy- excellent material. if you havent..].
this applies to NAFTA or the Eastern European Extension ["sponsored by Volkswagen"]- there will be a transition period of a few years where people may not cross freely. the difference in living and working conditions is maintained by reference to the romantic-reactionary nation-state model, which is, in its current form, a remnant of colonial imperialism and fascism. note that the bits re: slavery above put the illegal migrant at a very special position in the global economy, being both victim and enabler of pyramid-building at the national as well as the international level.
the minimal influx of migrants limits economic growth. germany is actually facing a huge disaster in terms of ageing population and a picture of "economic collapse by 2020" is being projected by pessimist economists [this is not to be taken too seriously as it is also part of an ideology of neo-liberal "reform" by the local tonys] if immigration is not increased to a couple of 100K a year. the german golden years of capitalism in the 50s and 60s were driven by a huge influx of workers which were actively recruited and sourced from different mediterranean countries to allow for the huge keynesian project of economic expanionism.
pyramid-building is not sensible in economic terms. low inflation, high interest, stable economies with minimal economic growth are best for the opulent minority who are hoarding cash and material value and worst for those living on wages. the influx of migrants is minimal and the disproportional noise ["commentary"] in the popular press is strongly ideological in nature. any analysis [consult left-liberal newspaper at hand] that does not take into account at least some of the [important] functional structures above will not get anywhere. political refugees coming from "failed states" (neo-colonial receiving end) are excluded from first world econ as "economic migrants" are- the science of creating and maintaining artifical barriers does not allow for exemptions.
the sad news is: going for "new, sensible immigration policy" is like advocating the re-introduction of keynesian economics: yes, it would help as far as any reform may. As marcuse says [196?, my translation + rough quote from memory] "reforms, anything that humanises the face of capitalism, can and must be tried. but there will always be a point when the reformist policy contradicts the pillar of the capitalist system, the principle of profit [or accelerated accumulation of capital]. Once this is breached, the question arises-- is revolution possible?"
far from wanting to criticise the proponent of any reformist stance, au contraire, my deepest respect and love to any vegetarian, fellow H&M purist, nudist, hedonist, gay pride, christian liberation theologist, long-hair, or whatever: it was the flawed discourse i was castigating. the rigity of a grammar that makes it all but impossible to express where its at. the self-censorship. the emotional frigidity. we must not be naive. i am sure that oxfam helps, that there are a lot of people "doing their best" on their ample allowances and london lifestyles, that they pull a number of brownies out of the dirt theyre in even..
if everything is thus connected to everything, there is one systemic totality, one functional rationale, with a vicious material reality to it [critical theoretical- in difference to marx, ?berbau is seen to be integral part of system], what is to be done?
it is possible to arrive at this question of questions from any theoretical starting point, whether it be a political economy of human rights, anti-psychiatry, radical ecology [primitivism], feminism, black power... these are all monkey attempts to understand own power. the question has not been asked properly, if there isnt some sort of resulting praxis!
who will be the first to have a cheeky crack at a radically new aesthetic in the new century? since those twisted romantics [nazis] fucked everything up, with the french intellectual promoting the continuation of said neo-romantic quest in true service to the lie, pillar to the grand gradients, there has been nothing. once creativity is unleashed, strong enough for subcutaneous realisation that "life is only a dream" etc, once the monkey-subject learns to realise itself:
again, marcuse: "we cannot know what the society of the future would look like, as we are unfree, and thus not able how a free subject would determine its mode of existence". it can only be found out in constant stuggle with the (imagined) rigidity of grammar, the (bullshit) ahistoricity claims to authoritarian language, overcoming the lack of belief in human action, fear of freedom... "there is no such thing as the revolutionary subject"- consciousness emerges in opposition to inertia, i.e. elements obstructing the process [negative dialectic]-
there will be fucking in the streets.
x
re: the migration issue, think that we veered away from the migration theme as such, in order to generally rant about institutions and the narrow scope of analysis when solving problems within the institutional structure (lack of adequate theory). the point being that institutional discourse is a complete farce. suppose that 'migration policy' was merely a case.
"immigrants aim to better their lives. They may aspire to be as rich as us and in the US their earnings usually overtake those of native born citizens in 10-15 years" - "the slave doesn't want to be free, he wants to be a master as benevolent as his own"
you are saying immigrants flee persecution/poverty. persecution/poverty which is precipitated by western intervention in developing countries, colonial history and resulting power gradients. obviously one has to practically help these individuals, i'm all for solidarity. but whether this language allows us to look at the bigger picture (reflective of power gradient), is a different question.
my point: merely showing solidarity with immigrants is almost like carpet bombing a village and then handing the victims a first aid kit (which is what we do). policy debate on our end would then be re: how much money to spend on post-war aid. and we'd feel so benevolent about it too.
so in a sense, debating re: how much money should be spent on foreign aid is implicitly accepting the war, or the imperialism/economic protectionism that caused the war. 'britain needs more immigrants' debate then, is implicitly accepting the power gradient that causes persecution/poverty/war for migrants to flee from in the first place ie. not reflective, just symptomatic treatment (a.k.a. reactionary whitewash).
what about that ft-reading scumbag on the central line?
so the rant is largely about the lack of critical reflection in institutional discourse. which isn't anything new/surprising at all really... positivist social science will never uncover anything that may be inconvenient.
in any case, this wasn't supposed to be a qualitative assessment of your, benji's, postings, especially not on the personal level. they merely offered matter for talk/rant/expression, x
"immigrants aim to better their lives. They may aspire to be as rich as us and in the US their earnings usually overtake those of native born citizens in 10-15 years" - "the slave doesn't want to be free, he wants to be a master as benevolent as his own"
you are saying immigrants flee persecution/poverty. persecution/poverty which is precipitated by western intervention in developing countries, colonial history and resulting power gradients. obviously one has to practically help these individuals, i'm all for solidarity. but whether this language allows us to look at the bigger picture (reflective of power gradient), is a different question.
my point: merely showing solidarity with immigrants is almost like carpet bombing a village and then handing the victims a first aid kit (which is what we do). policy debate on our end would then be re: how much money to spend on post-war aid. and we'd feel so benevolent about it too.
so in a sense, debating re: how much money should be spent on foreign aid is implicitly accepting the war, or the imperialism/economic protectionism that caused the war. 'britain needs more immigrants' debate then, is implicitly accepting the power gradient that causes persecution/poverty/war for migrants to flee from in the first place ie. not reflective, just symptomatic treatment (a.k.a. reactionary whitewash).
what about that ft-reading scumbag on the central line?
so the rant is largely about the lack of critical reflection in institutional discourse. which isn't anything new/surprising at all really... positivist social science will never uncover anything that may be inconvenient.
in any case, this wasn't supposed to be a qualitative assessment of your, benji's, postings, especially not on the personal level. they merely offered matter for talk/rant/expression, x
19.1.04
some notes on the debate below, which I don't follow entirely:
my posting on immigration are not about migrants having more neccesity of our pity than others... it just reflects my studies which are throwing up interesting (I think) stuff. If I studied human rights I would post legal/human rights stuff.
we must be careful to distinguish between asylum seekers, refugees and immigrants. Asylum seekers enter illegally (usually) and then claim asylum, if their claim is successful they get refugee status. Immigrants enter by applying for work permits, under a scheme designed by the government to fill jobs where they are needed.
asylum seekers flee persecution, some of them may aspire to be as rich as 'us', but that is not the reason they move.
immigrants aim to better their lives. They may aspire to be as rich as us and in the US their earnings usually overtake those of native born citizens in 10-15 years.
most of the other stuff I don't really get. No, capital is not amoral, yes, we are all implicated in this mess, No, it's not all our fault we were born into it, we can't suddenly or easily make everything better, but we can try and do something which is why I posted those posts about the plight of some individuals with suggested actions at the bottom.
I have posted an essay of mine, (yes, about immigration) which may be of interest to some, on the inquiry.
my posting on immigration are not about migrants having more neccesity of our pity than others... it just reflects my studies which are throwing up interesting (I think) stuff. If I studied human rights I would post legal/human rights stuff.
we must be careful to distinguish between asylum seekers, refugees and immigrants. Asylum seekers enter illegally (usually) and then claim asylum, if their claim is successful they get refugee status. Immigrants enter by applying for work permits, under a scheme designed by the government to fill jobs where they are needed.
asylum seekers flee persecution, some of them may aspire to be as rich as 'us', but that is not the reason they move.
immigrants aim to better their lives. They may aspire to be as rich as us and in the US their earnings usually overtake those of native born citizens in 10-15 years.
most of the other stuff I don't really get. No, capital is not amoral, yes, we are all implicated in this mess, No, it's not all our fault we were born into it, we can't suddenly or easily make everything better, but we can try and do something which is why I posted those posts about the plight of some individuals with suggested actions at the bottom.
I have posted an essay of mine, (yes, about immigration) which may be of interest to some, on the inquiry.
18.1.04
16.1.04
** fukuyama's nation-building 101 apology. as usual, it doesn't extent beyond imperialist polemic -> policy propaganda, ie. no point debating content.
"The first is that nation-building is a difficult, long-term enterprise with high costs in manpower, lives, and resources. The places where it has been most successful—Germany, Japan, and the Philippines—are ones where U.S. forces have remained for generations. We should not get involved to begin with if we are not willing to pay those high costs.
A standing U.S. government office to manage nation-building will be a hard sell politically, because we are still unreconciled to the idea that we are in the nation-building business for the long haul. However, international relations is no longer just a game played between great powers but one in which what happens inside smaller countries can have a huge effect on the rest of the world. Our "empire" may be a transitional one grounded in democracy and human rights, but our interests dictate that we learn how better to teach other people to govern themselves."
** america's empire of bases
"It's not easy to assess the size or exact value of our empire of bases. Official records on these subjects are misleading, although instructive. According to the Defense Department's annual "Base Structure Report" for fiscal year 2003, which itemizes foreign and domestic U.S. military real estate, the Pentagon currently owns or rents 702 overseas bases in about 130 countries and has another 6,000 bases in the United States and its territories. Pentagon bureaucrats calculate that it would require at least $113.2 billion to replace just the foreign bases – surely far too low a figure but still larger than the gross domestic product of most countries – and an estimated $591,519.8 million to replace all of them. The military high command deploys to our overseas bases some 253,288 uniformed personnel, plus an equal number of dependents and Department of Defense civilian officials, and employs an additional 44,446 locally hired foreigners."
"The first is that nation-building is a difficult, long-term enterprise with high costs in manpower, lives, and resources. The places where it has been most successful—Germany, Japan, and the Philippines—are ones where U.S. forces have remained for generations. We should not get involved to begin with if we are not willing to pay those high costs.
A standing U.S. government office to manage nation-building will be a hard sell politically, because we are still unreconciled to the idea that we are in the nation-building business for the long haul. However, international relations is no longer just a game played between great powers but one in which what happens inside smaller countries can have a huge effect on the rest of the world. Our "empire" may be a transitional one grounded in democracy and human rights, but our interests dictate that we learn how better to teach other people to govern themselves."
** america's empire of bases
"It's not easy to assess the size or exact value of our empire of bases. Official records on these subjects are misleading, although instructive. According to the Defense Department's annual "Base Structure Report" for fiscal year 2003, which itemizes foreign and domestic U.S. military real estate, the Pentagon currently owns or rents 702 overseas bases in about 130 countries and has another 6,000 bases in the United States and its territories. Pentagon bureaucrats calculate that it would require at least $113.2 billion to replace just the foreign bases – surely far too low a figure but still larger than the gross domestic product of most countries – and an estimated $591,519.8 million to replace all of them. The military high command deploys to our overseas bases some 253,288 uniformed personnel, plus an equal number of dependents and Department of Defense civilian officials, and employs an additional 44,446 locally hired foreigners."
15.1.04
re: "structural amorality of capital" - where was this from again?
synergy? it's like in positive right - not amorality (to speak of it like that would be too obvious within ius/ethica construct ;-)), but in critiques of extreme juidicial positivism (e.g. 'auctoritas non veritas...' etc.) one has introduced term 'deontological morality', which i received to be quite close to 'ethical neutrality'. this notion contains the instrumentalisation of ethical reason for political ends: the rationality of contractualist participation is based on premises about human nature via natural state argumentation, so the hypothetical or aprioric contract is as such already rationally instrumental and collective morality (ius) is subordinate to this ('auctoritas/veritas'). kant, in his ahistorical and obsessive universalism tried to get around it through his transcendental method of extrapolating the notion of right via reason apriori (via rationality itself !! - after horkheimer it feels like cheating...). hegel then looked at it through the telescope of totality and noticed a sense of instrumentality in the historical emergence of the moral subject (cf. sittlichkeit/categorical imperative). anyway, we've been through this ;-). synergy then, in the sense of a structural amorality of institutions via ius (-> discourse -> ideology -> advanced industrial society -> whole goddamn business).
have noted that "for the common good" argumentation seems to rely heavily on such reductions of moral reason or ethical suspension.
when will contemporary ideology finally reflect this? obv. only after institutions have been ideologically "reduced to ashes", hence i can only agree, that there is an integrative nature in protest against institutional policy, that fails to analyse the institution's underlying mechanisms, legitimacy or even the notion of 'such a thing' (in ppp language: polity prior to policy). to be anti-wef or anti-american is merely a response to the flawed institutional excuse (washington consensus/united nations/nation states) without identifying it as such, so using the same language, therefore similarly pseudoconcrete. this isn't about "abstract entities" such as the modern nation state, certain regimes and their policies, as much as it's about us, our neighbours and everybody else. the world of appearances does not disclose that one can/must dig deeper than that. policy analysis (thereby including the acceptance of the institution that formulated it) has thus a purely phenomenal function and shouldn't inform political praxis directly which, in this ahistorical way, can only be formulated as a superficial reaction (nothing the state can't handle etc). as phil describes ("evil outthere" whilst "suv-driving neighbour"). perhaps this structure contains threads similar to 'really-existing socialism' vs. libertarian socialism, but that's just an interesting feeling ;-).
title of debate also telling (functional grammar -> fascist syntax): "britain [subject] needs more immigrants [accusative object]" - aren't we staring instrumental reason/ethical neutrality in the face there? this is not about the perpetrators (hiding behind subject), nor is it about the immigrants even (intransitive object)! it's about "abstract entity" britain (subject) - a policy debate with an extraparliamentary nature that is misleading. the real question as below, it seems, is why the west needs more immigrants whilst being unable to wash the "common good" excuse any longer to much success - we are in fact on the same titanic as asylumseekers are. upper or lower deck, the boat still sunk. only difference is that we have the material means to believe that there is an 'us' and 'them'. and the asylumseeker obviously strives to be as rich as 'us' (the slave doesn't want to be free, he wants to be a master as benevolent as his own - both alienated). our solidarity with immigrants then, if that's all we can come up with, might just reduce us to benevolent masters...
protest within the framework usually leads to implicit acceptance of issue at hand. seeming anti-systemic forces are healthy after all ("we need no passport people to run first world economy, brownies without labour or indeed any rights are as necessary to the maintenance of our luxurious lifestyle as the slaves of ancient rome") ie. to act on such issues on the nation-state or institutional level is almost like accepting the lies. one might as well be talking micro/meso/macrolevel all day.
of course, there's nothing wrong with the dynamic of immigration solidarity. but locality of issue and discourse (both empirically and intelligibly) lets one wonder about the critical-revolutionary potential of such action. in good reformist tradition: it's tackling the right outcomes, but remains beside the actual problem. we can sit around debating governmental policy as much as we want, but in the end we'll still treat the concept of our suv-driving, viagra-popping neighbour/boss/professor/priest with an acceptance like no dystopian vision had ever entered our minds.
anyway ("coitus? i was talking about my rug...") was only going to refer to synergy, so: there might be insights to be gained by looking at establishment of ethical neutrality within both capital flow and sittlichkeit (essentially political economy), exposing mechanisms of functional rationality/instrumental reason within and between base and superstructure -> institutions.
but then again, this exposure is what any creative work represents.
synergy? it's like in positive right - not amorality (to speak of it like that would be too obvious within ius/ethica construct ;-)), but in critiques of extreme juidicial positivism (e.g. 'auctoritas non veritas...' etc.) one has introduced term 'deontological morality', which i received to be quite close to 'ethical neutrality'. this notion contains the instrumentalisation of ethical reason for political ends: the rationality of contractualist participation is based on premises about human nature via natural state argumentation, so the hypothetical or aprioric contract is as such already rationally instrumental and collective morality (ius) is subordinate to this ('auctoritas/veritas'). kant, in his ahistorical and obsessive universalism tried to get around it through his transcendental method of extrapolating the notion of right via reason apriori (via rationality itself !! - after horkheimer it feels like cheating...). hegel then looked at it through the telescope of totality and noticed a sense of instrumentality in the historical emergence of the moral subject (cf. sittlichkeit/categorical imperative). anyway, we've been through this ;-). synergy then, in the sense of a structural amorality of institutions via ius (-> discourse -> ideology -> advanced industrial society -> whole goddamn business).
have noted that "for the common good" argumentation seems to rely heavily on such reductions of moral reason or ethical suspension.
when will contemporary ideology finally reflect this? obv. only after institutions have been ideologically "reduced to ashes", hence i can only agree, that there is an integrative nature in protest against institutional policy, that fails to analyse the institution's underlying mechanisms, legitimacy or even the notion of 'such a thing' (in ppp language: polity prior to policy). to be anti-wef or anti-american is merely a response to the flawed institutional excuse (washington consensus/united nations/nation states) without identifying it as such, so using the same language, therefore similarly pseudoconcrete. this isn't about "abstract entities" such as the modern nation state, certain regimes and their policies, as much as it's about us, our neighbours and everybody else. the world of appearances does not disclose that one can/must dig deeper than that. policy analysis (thereby including the acceptance of the institution that formulated it) has thus a purely phenomenal function and shouldn't inform political praxis directly which, in this ahistorical way, can only be formulated as a superficial reaction (nothing the state can't handle etc). as phil describes ("evil outthere" whilst "suv-driving neighbour"). perhaps this structure contains threads similar to 'really-existing socialism' vs. libertarian socialism, but that's just an interesting feeling ;-).
title of debate also telling (functional grammar -> fascist syntax): "britain [subject] needs more immigrants [accusative object]" - aren't we staring instrumental reason/ethical neutrality in the face there? this is not about the perpetrators (hiding behind subject), nor is it about the immigrants even (intransitive object)! it's about "abstract entity" britain (subject) - a policy debate with an extraparliamentary nature that is misleading. the real question as below, it seems, is why the west needs more immigrants whilst being unable to wash the "common good" excuse any longer to much success - we are in fact on the same titanic as asylumseekers are. upper or lower deck, the boat still sunk. only difference is that we have the material means to believe that there is an 'us' and 'them'. and the asylumseeker obviously strives to be as rich as 'us' (the slave doesn't want to be free, he wants to be a master as benevolent as his own - both alienated). our solidarity with immigrants then, if that's all we can come up with, might just reduce us to benevolent masters...
protest within the framework usually leads to implicit acceptance of issue at hand. seeming anti-systemic forces are healthy after all ("we need no passport people to run first world economy, brownies without labour or indeed any rights are as necessary to the maintenance of our luxurious lifestyle as the slaves of ancient rome") ie. to act on such issues on the nation-state or institutional level is almost like accepting the lies. one might as well be talking micro/meso/macrolevel all day.
of course, there's nothing wrong with the dynamic of immigration solidarity. but locality of issue and discourse (both empirically and intelligibly) lets one wonder about the critical-revolutionary potential of such action. in good reformist tradition: it's tackling the right outcomes, but remains beside the actual problem. we can sit around debating governmental policy as much as we want, but in the end we'll still treat the concept of our suv-driving, viagra-popping neighbour/boss/professor/priest with an acceptance like no dystopian vision had ever entered our minds.
anyway ("coitus? i was talking about my rug...") was only going to refer to synergy, so: there might be insights to be gained by looking at establishment of ethical neutrality within both capital flow and sittlichkeit (essentially political economy), exposing mechanisms of functional rationality/instrumental reason within and between base and superstructure -> institutions.
but then again, this exposure is what any creative work represents.
email to mike
feel like writing long CL blogger comment but cannot be fucked to get into really. this "poor migrants" theme is unfortunately just as flawed as anti-globals are in terms of lacking adequate theory to overcome (dys)functional grammar.
theres plenty of talk of who the victims are, theres plenty of talk of the structural and legal problems theyre facing. issue with migrants: we need no passport people to run first world economy, brownies without labour or indeed any rights are as necessary to the maintenance of our luxurious lifestyle as the slaves of ancient rome. perhaps a little less so. but the scope for an extension of minimum wage in britain (to everybody!) just aint there. military spending is through the roof, the 90s economic miracle is a total farce, etc ppp. these victims know the perpetrators. we know them. noones talking about that.
same applies to anti-globals. WTO is bad, IMF is evil. there are a number of evil upper class yanks. but us, in our holy grace, we aint touched by evil because we're against these things. the class of beneficiaries are the managers/thieves and "inbred heirs" who are our SUV-(or otherwise)-owning neighbours right here in OECD suburbia. the ugly evil "out there" or whatever are the corporate scumbags sitting next to you on the london tube. of course there is no active evil, everybody's doing their best and their bit, as meritocracy and indeed any agent-operator participating somewhere up there in the global power structure will tell you:
just doing best for company and thus for share- and stakeholders. and we certainly are stake- if not even shareholders to the current order. ideology is the sum of heuristic mechanisms keeping people blind to the structural logic that leads to the sort of social reality we (to some extent) and brownie kiddies throughout the world are facing. shareholdership is supposedly ethically neutral due to the (assumed) structural amorality of capital, i.e. money don't stink, its only some oil barons and arms manufacturers without U.N. whitewash who smell.. the managers themselves, however, are anonymous. this supposed ethical neutrality of (abstract-form) capital also allows for illusionary "selective consumption"- no nestle (babymilk), no esso (hasnt implemented adequate greenwash) etc..
neither is a european social forum held in paris where only kids of first world elites can actually afford to attend. or a world social forum in mumbay. mobility in third world = zero. participation = 20 USD or whatever. this excludes anyone but the elites. at least its left-leaning third world elites.. getting 25K job working in london oxfam is no way to break functional rationale. maybe even blogging isnt..
have a nice day..
feel like writing long CL blogger comment but cannot be fucked to get into really. this "poor migrants" theme is unfortunately just as flawed as anti-globals are in terms of lacking adequate theory to overcome (dys)functional grammar.
theres plenty of talk of who the victims are, theres plenty of talk of the structural and legal problems theyre facing. issue with migrants: we need no passport people to run first world economy, brownies without labour or indeed any rights are as necessary to the maintenance of our luxurious lifestyle as the slaves of ancient rome. perhaps a little less so. but the scope for an extension of minimum wage in britain (to everybody!) just aint there. military spending is through the roof, the 90s economic miracle is a total farce, etc ppp. these victims know the perpetrators. we know them. noones talking about that.
same applies to anti-globals. WTO is bad, IMF is evil. there are a number of evil upper class yanks. but us, in our holy grace, we aint touched by evil because we're against these things. the class of beneficiaries are the managers/thieves and "inbred heirs" who are our SUV-(or otherwise)-owning neighbours right here in OECD suburbia. the ugly evil "out there" or whatever are the corporate scumbags sitting next to you on the london tube. of course there is no active evil, everybody's doing their best and their bit, as meritocracy and indeed any agent-operator participating somewhere up there in the global power structure will tell you:
just doing best for company and thus for share- and stakeholders. and we certainly are stake- if not even shareholders to the current order. ideology is the sum of heuristic mechanisms keeping people blind to the structural logic that leads to the sort of social reality we (to some extent) and brownie kiddies throughout the world are facing. shareholdership is supposedly ethically neutral due to the (assumed) structural amorality of capital, i.e. money don't stink, its only some oil barons and arms manufacturers without U.N. whitewash who smell.. the managers themselves, however, are anonymous. this supposed ethical neutrality of (abstract-form) capital also allows for illusionary "selective consumption"- no nestle (babymilk), no esso (hasnt implemented adequate greenwash) etc..
neither is a european social forum held in paris where only kids of first world elites can actually afford to attend. or a world social forum in mumbay. mobility in third world = zero. participation = 20 USD or whatever. this excludes anyone but the elites. at least its left-leaning third world elites.. getting 25K job working in london oxfam is no way to break functional rationale. maybe even blogging isnt..
have a nice day..
Baghdad hotel killings result of 'criminal negligence', says media watchdog. The journalists killed in Bagdad by a US tank... this was big news in Spain, where Jose Couso, one of the journalists was from. The Jose Couso site has some interesting articles and letters.
"It led to a media outcry at the time - Spanish journalists snubbed a visit by the foreign minister, Jack Straw, to Madrid shortly afterwards, downing cameras, notebooks and holding their heads in silence during a speech."
Probably quite an over reported story, but here is the Guardian report
"It led to a media outcry at the time - Spanish journalists snubbed a visit by the foreign minister, Jack Straw, to Madrid shortly afterwards, downing cameras, notebooks and holding their heads in silence during a speech."
Probably quite an over reported story, but here is the Guardian report
I just saw this excellent film by Sierra Leonean film maker Sorious Samura, I recomend him.
It's called Exodus, and it's about illegal immigration into the EU from Africa. It is clever without being academic and sensitive without being over the top. On the linked website are more of his films, which I'd like to check out.
It's called Exodus, and it's about illegal immigration into the EU from Africa. It is clever without being academic and sensitive without being over the top. On the linked website are more of his films, which I'd like to check out.
14.1.04
National Coalition of Anti-Deportation Campaigns (NCADC)
1 Delaunays Road
Manchester
M8 4QS
General enquiries 0121 554 6947
ncadc@ncadc.org.uk
http://www.ncadc.org.uk/
Stop the deportation of Ebana Dieudonne
(Urgent Action needed before next Sunday)
Another attempt to remove Ebana from the UK will take place this Sunday 18th January 2004.
Ebana Dieudonne, a national of Cameroon, is currently detained in Tinsley House Removal/Detention Centre, where he has been since 10th December. Prior to Tinsley House, he was held in Harmondsworth detention centre since 7th November.
Ebana is in a state of extreme distress. This state is exacerbated by his detention which is affecting him physically and emotionally. Ebana fears that if he is returned to Cameroon, he will be arrested upon arrival and imprisoned or killed. He has good grounds for these fears.
Ebana has had a gay relationship with his employer, a high level politician, for over two years. In Cameroon, homosexuality is illegal. Section 347 of the Penal Code criminalises sexual contacts with members of the same sex with a penalty of up to 5 years' imprisonment. Ebana identifies as gay, but was also married to a woman in Cameroon, who was fully aware of his relationship with his employer.
Before Ebana left Cameroon he was visited by the police on the evening of 22nd October in his home and questioned on the nature of his relationship with his employer. Ebana denied any sexual contact. The police issued a summons for him to come to the police station on the morning of the 29th October, and said he would be taken to the hospital for tests (anal examinations are sometimes carried out in such cases supposedly to determine if anal sex has occurred. These examinations are in fact unreliable and have no scientific basis, but may be used as spurious evidence, and to humiliate and abuse suspects).
Ebana suspects that his relationship with his employer had been observed and informed upon due to political motivations in order to undermine his employer's political position.
After the police visit to Ebana's home, his employer asked him to provide passport photos of himself. On the evening of the 28th, his employer called Ebana to his visit him, gave him travel documents, and ordered him to be taken to the airport and out of the country. Ebana protested that he should first say goodbye to his wife and family, but his employer threatened to kill him if he did not leave immediately. Ebana complied, and thus arrived in the UK.
Ebana has since phoned a friend in Cameroon who informed him his wife was murdered in November after his departure. Ebana believes that his wife would have sought out his employer after his sudden disappearance, and that his employer would have had his wife murdered in order to silence her.
Ebana fears that upon return he will be arrested and imprisoned by the state for homosexuality, or murdered by his employer in order to protect his own reputation.
The Home Office has turned down Ebana's application on grounds that he is not a credible witness. However, his solicitor did not turn up to the last hearing, so he was left to present his own case. Ebana has little understanding of the asylum system, and indeed had never heard of asylum until after his arrival in the UK. There are also difficulties in discussing gay relationships and identity when one has just come from a country where homosexuality can result in persecution and imprisonment.
Ebana will be at serious risk of imprisonment and death if he is returned to the Cameroon. He has a good case to be allowed to remain in the UK on grounds of human rights, in particular the right not to be returned to a country where he is likely to be subjected to cruel and inhuman treatment or punishment.
Several Cameroonian homosexuals have been awarded asylum in Belgium under the Geneva Convention due to the persecutions they suffered in Cameroon. The UK is also party to the Geneva Convention.
A previous attempt to remove Ebana on the 9th December failed. We are trying to persuade the home office not to deport Ebana this Sunday, and to reconsider his case.
What you can do to help:
1) Telephone Ebana at Tynsley House 01293 434800, his first language is French, let Ebana know you are supporting him. You can also fax him a letter of Solidarity direct fax number for detainees at Tynsley House 01293 434825.
2) Fax/write to the Home Secretary requesting that Ebana Dieudonne is allowed to stay. You can use the model letter attached. Copy/amend/write your own version, feel free to add your own comments.
You can fax David Blunkett on 020 7273 3965, or from outside the UK +44 20 7373 3965
Or write direct:
David Blunkett
Home Secretary
Home Office
50 Queen Anne's Gate
London SW1H 9AT
Please notify the campaign of any letters/faxes sent: mailto:shuangxinglian@hotmail.com
Enquiries/further information:
Ebana Dieudonne Must Stay Campaign
NCADC
131 Camberwell Road
London SE5 0HF
0121 554 6947
1 Delaunays Road
Manchester
M8 4QS
General enquiries 0121 554 6947
ncadc@ncadc.org.uk
http://www.ncadc.org.uk/
Stop the deportation of Ebana Dieudonne
(Urgent Action needed before next Sunday)
Another attempt to remove Ebana from the UK will take place this Sunday 18th January 2004.
Ebana Dieudonne, a national of Cameroon, is currently detained in Tinsley House Removal/Detention Centre, where he has been since 10th December. Prior to Tinsley House, he was held in Harmondsworth detention centre since 7th November.
Ebana is in a state of extreme distress. This state is exacerbated by his detention which is affecting him physically and emotionally. Ebana fears that if he is returned to Cameroon, he will be arrested upon arrival and imprisoned or killed. He has good grounds for these fears.
Ebana has had a gay relationship with his employer, a high level politician, for over two years. In Cameroon, homosexuality is illegal. Section 347 of the Penal Code criminalises sexual contacts with members of the same sex with a penalty of up to 5 years' imprisonment. Ebana identifies as gay, but was also married to a woman in Cameroon, who was fully aware of his relationship with his employer.
Before Ebana left Cameroon he was visited by the police on the evening of 22nd October in his home and questioned on the nature of his relationship with his employer. Ebana denied any sexual contact. The police issued a summons for him to come to the police station on the morning of the 29th October, and said he would be taken to the hospital for tests (anal examinations are sometimes carried out in such cases supposedly to determine if anal sex has occurred. These examinations are in fact unreliable and have no scientific basis, but may be used as spurious evidence, and to humiliate and abuse suspects).
Ebana suspects that his relationship with his employer had been observed and informed upon due to political motivations in order to undermine his employer's political position.
After the police visit to Ebana's home, his employer asked him to provide passport photos of himself. On the evening of the 28th, his employer called Ebana to his visit him, gave him travel documents, and ordered him to be taken to the airport and out of the country. Ebana protested that he should first say goodbye to his wife and family, but his employer threatened to kill him if he did not leave immediately. Ebana complied, and thus arrived in the UK.
Ebana has since phoned a friend in Cameroon who informed him his wife was murdered in November after his departure. Ebana believes that his wife would have sought out his employer after his sudden disappearance, and that his employer would have had his wife murdered in order to silence her.
Ebana fears that upon return he will be arrested and imprisoned by the state for homosexuality, or murdered by his employer in order to protect his own reputation.
The Home Office has turned down Ebana's application on grounds that he is not a credible witness. However, his solicitor did not turn up to the last hearing, so he was left to present his own case. Ebana has little understanding of the asylum system, and indeed had never heard of asylum until after his arrival in the UK. There are also difficulties in discussing gay relationships and identity when one has just come from a country where homosexuality can result in persecution and imprisonment.
Ebana will be at serious risk of imprisonment and death if he is returned to the Cameroon. He has a good case to be allowed to remain in the UK on grounds of human rights, in particular the right not to be returned to a country where he is likely to be subjected to cruel and inhuman treatment or punishment.
Several Cameroonian homosexuals have been awarded asylum in Belgium under the Geneva Convention due to the persecutions they suffered in Cameroon. The UK is also party to the Geneva Convention.
A previous attempt to remove Ebana on the 9th December failed. We are trying to persuade the home office not to deport Ebana this Sunday, and to reconsider his case.
What you can do to help:
1) Telephone Ebana at Tynsley House 01293 434800, his first language is French, let Ebana know you are supporting him. You can also fax him a letter of Solidarity direct fax number for detainees at Tynsley House 01293 434825.
2) Fax/write to the Home Secretary requesting that Ebana Dieudonne is allowed to stay. You can use the model letter attached. Copy/amend/write your own version, feel free to add your own comments.
You can fax David Blunkett on 020 7273 3965, or from outside the UK +44 20 7373 3965
Or write direct:
David Blunkett
Home Secretary
Home Office
50 Queen Anne's Gate
London SW1H 9AT
Please notify the campaign of any letters/faxes sent: mailto:shuangxinglian@hotmail.com
Enquiries/further information:
Ebana Dieudonne Must Stay Campaign
NCADC
131 Camberwell Road
London SE5 0HF
0121 554 6947
European day of action for the rights of asylum seekers, Sans-Papiers and immigrants: 31 January 2004
Dear sisters, brothers and friends,
For several months a number of organisations of immigrant people and supporters have been building a network against “Fortress Europe”. We recently met with some of these groups, on the initiative of the Paris-based Droits Devant, and we agreed with them to call for a joint Day of Action on 31 January 2004 to defend the human rights of all “Sans Papiers” (people without papers) – immigrants and asylum seekers who are denied rights to residence, housing, work permits, healthcare, benefits, etc.
So far, co-ordinated actions are planned in Belgium, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Spain, Switzerland and the UK – you may have heard from other UK-based groups already. The aim is to make visible the deprivation and destitution faced by those of us who are asylum seekers or immigrants and the struggle we are making for human rights.
In our network many of the women asylum seekers -- rape survivors, pregnant women, mothers with young children, women with serious health problems often as a result of torture, lesbian women, women who speak no English, and women who are vulnerable in other ways -- are homeless and destitute. Detention, forced dispersal, deportation and racist attacks are increasing. We may be forced into begging or prostitution to feed ourselves and our families, facing further criminalisation. We know that throughout Europe others are facing the same crises and organising against them.
At a time of increased wars and poverty in Third World countries caused by Western economic and military interests, and of immigration policies which reek more and more of Nazism, we are taking action together to show our unity across national borders against racism and all discrimination. As immigrants and asylum seekers and as Europeans we stand together to demand that the West pay its debt to the Third World. We defend and strengthen all our movements against the increasing threat to our most basic rights. We show how many of us in Europe are appalled by this return to Nazism – reinforced by Europe’s allegiance to Bush’s US – which millions everywhere died to defeat. We will not allow immigrants to be scapegoated for cuts in benefits, wages, pensions and healthcare imposed by market forces that don’t value any of our lives.
Our 31 January action will be the first action of the 2004 Global Women’s Strike. It will be an opportunity for us to highlight the situations and struggles of women asylum seekers, which are most neglected, making them visible internationally. The Strike demands that society Invests in Caring Not Killing – a complete change from the economic priorities of the market and the return of military budgets to the
community, beginning with women the first carers. Women, and men who support our goals, are building to take Strike action in over 60 countries on 8 March (International Women’s Day).(see http://globalwomenstrike.net for more info). A collective manifesto and demands are being drafted for 31 January (see below) and the final version will be circulated soon.
Demands
Unconditional regularisation (right to stay) for all Sans-Papiers, and freedom of movement and settlement. Capital travels freely, why not people?
Immediate closure of all detention camps in all European countries
An end to all deportations
The right to citizenship and permanent residency for all, in all European countries, including access to the same healthcare, benefits, education and other resources that everyone else needs
Implementation of a real right to asylum, including official recognition of rape as persecution and therefore grounds for asylum
Recognition of the specific needs of women asylum seekers, immigrants and refugees, as those who are most likely to have responsibility for the care of others, are most vulnerable to violence, and least able to escape persecution or get the resources to settle when we do
An end to exploitation and neo-slavery, and the right to work based on the same entitlements as the workers in the country where we settle
We will shortly be letting you know more about our exciting plans. Please let us know if you are interested in taking part.
Women of Colour (Global Women’s Strike)
Crossroads Women’s Centre, 230A Kentish Town Road, London NW5 2AB
Tel: 0207 482 2496 Fax: 0207 209 4761 email:womenofcolour@allwomencount.net
Payday
PO Box 287 London NW6 5QU, Tel 0207 209 4751
Email payday@paydaynet.org web: www.refusingtokill.net
9 Jan 2004
Last week the Liverpool Committee Against Destitution For Asylum Seekers (LCAD) called a nation-wide protest Stand Up for Asylum Seekers marking the first year of the hated Sections 55 & 57 of the Immigration & Nationality Act. For more info contact: Dee Coombes lcad@merseymail.com
Dear sisters, brothers and friends,
For several months a number of organisations of immigrant people and supporters have been building a network against “Fortress Europe”. We recently met with some of these groups, on the initiative of the Paris-based Droits Devant, and we agreed with them to call for a joint Day of Action on 31 January 2004 to defend the human rights of all “Sans Papiers” (people without papers) – immigrants and asylum seekers who are denied rights to residence, housing, work permits, healthcare, benefits, etc.
So far, co-ordinated actions are planned in Belgium, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Spain, Switzerland and the UK – you may have heard from other UK-based groups already. The aim is to make visible the deprivation and destitution faced by those of us who are asylum seekers or immigrants and the struggle we are making for human rights.
In our network many of the women asylum seekers -- rape survivors, pregnant women, mothers with young children, women with serious health problems often as a result of torture, lesbian women, women who speak no English, and women who are vulnerable in other ways -- are homeless and destitute. Detention, forced dispersal, deportation and racist attacks are increasing. We may be forced into begging or prostitution to feed ourselves and our families, facing further criminalisation. We know that throughout Europe others are facing the same crises and organising against them.
At a time of increased wars and poverty in Third World countries caused by Western economic and military interests, and of immigration policies which reek more and more of Nazism, we are taking action together to show our unity across national borders against racism and all discrimination. As immigrants and asylum seekers and as Europeans we stand together to demand that the West pay its debt to the Third World. We defend and strengthen all our movements against the increasing threat to our most basic rights. We show how many of us in Europe are appalled by this return to Nazism – reinforced by Europe’s allegiance to Bush’s US – which millions everywhere died to defeat. We will not allow immigrants to be scapegoated for cuts in benefits, wages, pensions and healthcare imposed by market forces that don’t value any of our lives.
Our 31 January action will be the first action of the 2004 Global Women’s Strike. It will be an opportunity for us to highlight the situations and struggles of women asylum seekers, which are most neglected, making them visible internationally. The Strike demands that society Invests in Caring Not Killing – a complete change from the economic priorities of the market and the return of military budgets to the
community, beginning with women the first carers. Women, and men who support our goals, are building to take Strike action in over 60 countries on 8 March (International Women’s Day).(see http://globalwomenstrike.net for more info). A collective manifesto and demands are being drafted for 31 January (see below) and the final version will be circulated soon.
Demands
Unconditional regularisation (right to stay) for all Sans-Papiers, and freedom of movement and settlement. Capital travels freely, why not people?
Immediate closure of all detention camps in all European countries
An end to all deportations
The right to citizenship and permanent residency for all, in all European countries, including access to the same healthcare, benefits, education and other resources that everyone else needs
Implementation of a real right to asylum, including official recognition of rape as persecution and therefore grounds for asylum
Recognition of the specific needs of women asylum seekers, immigrants and refugees, as those who are most likely to have responsibility for the care of others, are most vulnerable to violence, and least able to escape persecution or get the resources to settle when we do
An end to exploitation and neo-slavery, and the right to work based on the same entitlements as the workers in the country where we settle
We will shortly be letting you know more about our exciting plans. Please let us know if you are interested in taking part.
Women of Colour (Global Women’s Strike)
Crossroads Women’s Centre, 230A Kentish Town Road, London NW5 2AB
Tel: 0207 482 2496 Fax: 0207 209 4761 email:womenofcolour@allwomencount.net
Payday
PO Box 287 London NW6 5QU, Tel 0207 209 4751
Email payday@paydaynet.org web: www.refusingtokill.net
9 Jan 2004
Last week the Liverpool Committee Against Destitution For Asylum Seekers (LCAD) called a nation-wide protest Stand Up for Asylum Seekers marking the first year of the hated Sections 55 & 57 of the Immigration & Nationality Act. For more info contact: Dee Coombes lcad@merseymail.com
** us sets up imperial outpost in mauritania:
"A small vanguard force arrived this week in Mauritania to pave the way for a $100m (£54m) plan to bolster the security forces and border controls of Mauritania, Mali, Chad and Niger.
The US Pan-Sahel Initiative, as it is named, will provide 60 days of training to military units, including tips on desert navigation and infantry tactics, and furnish equipment such as Toyota Land Cruisers, radios and uniforms."
this being part of us initiative to secure oil and military presence in africa (7/7/03):
"General James Jones, the commander of the US European command with responsibility for African operations, said the US was trying to negotiate the long-term use of a "family" of military bases across the continent.
"The bases would not only be established in north African states such as Algeria, where Islamic extremism is already a potent force, but also in sub-Saharan African nations such as Mali.
[...]
The new bases are being described as temporary, but in reality, once built they are likely to become part of the African landscape.
[...]
The Djibouti base is in striking distance of Sudan, Somalia and Yemen, all seen as possible havens for al-Qaida. But bases in West Africa and an enhanced naval presence in the Gulf of Guinea would be primarily designed to safeguard an increasingly important source of oil.
The US is currently importing 1.5m barrels a day from West Africa, about the same as imports from Saudi Arabia. Meanwhile the US has so far invested $10bn (?6bn) in the West African oil fields this year. The US department of energy expects African oil imports to reach 770m barrels a year, and US investment in the oil fields to exceed $10bn a year.
At a meeting organised last month by the Corporate Council on Africa, a senior CIA official, David Gordon, predicted that over the next decade African oil would be potentially more important to the US than Russia or the Caucasus. According to other participants at the meeting, he went on to warn however that over the following decade the oil industry ran the risk of imploding as a result of the region's inherent instability, unless the US did more to prop it up."
** bush to waste $1.5 billion for promotion of marriage:
"For months, administration officials have worked with conservative groups on the proposal, which would provide at least $1.5 billion for training to help couples develop interpersonal skills that sustain "healthy marriages."
"no wonder we're fucked up as a race" - bill hicks
also found this amusing ad on the nyt site whilst reading above
clicked it and it led me to this very selective, most naive and outright dumb description of "marijuana":
"Usually smoked as a cigarette or joint, or in a pipe or bong, marijuana has appeared in "blunts" in recent years. These are cigars that have been emptied of tobacco and re-filled with marijuana, sometimes in combination with another drug, such as crack."
with following disclaimer:
"TheAntiDrug.com relies on the latest research to bring you the most accurate information available."
"A small vanguard force arrived this week in Mauritania to pave the way for a $100m (£54m) plan to bolster the security forces and border controls of Mauritania, Mali, Chad and Niger.
The US Pan-Sahel Initiative, as it is named, will provide 60 days of training to military units, including tips on desert navigation and infantry tactics, and furnish equipment such as Toyota Land Cruisers, radios and uniforms."
this being part of us initiative to secure oil and military presence in africa (7/7/03):
"General James Jones, the commander of the US European command with responsibility for African operations, said the US was trying to negotiate the long-term use of a "family" of military bases across the continent.
"The bases would not only be established in north African states such as Algeria, where Islamic extremism is already a potent force, but also in sub-Saharan African nations such as Mali.
[...]
The new bases are being described as temporary, but in reality, once built they are likely to become part of the African landscape.
[...]
The Djibouti base is in striking distance of Sudan, Somalia and Yemen, all seen as possible havens for al-Qaida. But bases in West Africa and an enhanced naval presence in the Gulf of Guinea would be primarily designed to safeguard an increasingly important source of oil.
The US is currently importing 1.5m barrels a day from West Africa, about the same as imports from Saudi Arabia. Meanwhile the US has so far invested $10bn (?6bn) in the West African oil fields this year. The US department of energy expects African oil imports to reach 770m barrels a year, and US investment in the oil fields to exceed $10bn a year.
At a meeting organised last month by the Corporate Council on Africa, a senior CIA official, David Gordon, predicted that over the next decade African oil would be potentially more important to the US than Russia or the Caucasus. According to other participants at the meeting, he went on to warn however that over the following decade the oil industry ran the risk of imploding as a result of the region's inherent instability, unless the US did more to prop it up."
** bush to waste $1.5 billion for promotion of marriage:
"For months, administration officials have worked with conservative groups on the proposal, which would provide at least $1.5 billion for training to help couples develop interpersonal skills that sustain "healthy marriages."
"no wonder we're fucked up as a race" - bill hicks
also found this amusing ad on the nyt site whilst reading above
clicked it and it led me to this very selective, most naive and outright dumb description of "marijuana":
"Usually smoked as a cigarette or joint, or in a pipe or bong, marijuana has appeared in "blunts" in recent years. These are cigars that have been emptied of tobacco and re-filled with marijuana, sometimes in combination with another drug, such as crack."
with following disclaimer:
"TheAntiDrug.com relies on the latest research to bring you the most accurate information available."
Debate
BRITAIN NEEDS MORE IMMIGRANTS
22nd January 2004
Speaking FOR the motion:
Dr Heaven Crawley,
Associate Director (Migration & Equalities) at IPPR, one of Britain's leading progressive think tanks.
Barbara Roche MP,
Labour MP for Hornsey and Wood Green. Former Minister of State in the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (until June 2003), where her ministerial responsibilities included Social Exclusion, Regional Co-ordination, Neighbourhood Renewal, Homelessness, Women and Equalities. Former Home Office Minister with responsibilities for Immigration, Asylum and European Policy.
Speaking AGAINST the motion:
Sir Andrew Green,
Chairman and founder of Migration Watch UK, an independent think-tank which seeks to provide comprehensible information and to encourage open debate on asylum and immigration. Former British Ambassador in Syria and Saudi Arabia.
Professor Robert Rowthorn,
A Fellow of Kings College, Professor of Economics and until recently Chair of the Faculty of Economics and Politics at Cambridge University. He is the author of several books and many academic articles on economic growth, unemployment, globalisation and related issues.
Chaired by:
Philip Collins,
Director of the Social Market Foundation. His main research interests are in the fields of education and race and nationhood and his first novel, "The Men From The Boys" was published in January 2002.
Venue: The Royal Geographical Society, 1 Kensington Gore, London, SW7 (entrance to the debate is on Exhibition Road)
Time: Doors open at 6.00pm. Debate starts at 6.45pm and finishes at 8.30pm.
Tickets: £20 per ticket
Bookings: Tel: 020 7494 3345 or email info@intelligencesquared.com.
BRITAIN NEEDS MORE IMMIGRANTS
22nd January 2004
Speaking FOR the motion:
Dr Heaven Crawley,
Associate Director (Migration & Equalities) at IPPR, one of Britain's leading progressive think tanks.
Barbara Roche MP,
Labour MP for Hornsey and Wood Green. Former Minister of State in the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (until June 2003), where her ministerial responsibilities included Social Exclusion, Regional Co-ordination, Neighbourhood Renewal, Homelessness, Women and Equalities. Former Home Office Minister with responsibilities for Immigration, Asylum and European Policy.
Speaking AGAINST the motion:
Sir Andrew Green,
Chairman and founder of Migration Watch UK, an independent think-tank which seeks to provide comprehensible information and to encourage open debate on asylum and immigration. Former British Ambassador in Syria and Saudi Arabia.
Professor Robert Rowthorn,
A Fellow of Kings College, Professor of Economics and until recently Chair of the Faculty of Economics and Politics at Cambridge University. He is the author of several books and many academic articles on economic growth, unemployment, globalisation and related issues.
Chaired by:
Philip Collins,
Director of the Social Market Foundation. His main research interests are in the fields of education and race and nationhood and his first novel, "The Men From The Boys" was published in January 2002.
Venue: The Royal Geographical Society, 1 Kensington Gore, London, SW7 (entrance to the debate is on Exhibition Road)
Time: Doors open at 6.00pm. Debate starts at 6.45pm and finishes at 8.30pm.
Tickets: £20 per ticket
Bookings: Tel: 020 7494 3345 or email info@intelligencesquared.com.
lenny pardoned - 23/12/03
"New York Governor George Pataki today granted a posthumous pardon to Lenny Bruce, wiping away the comedian's 1964 obscenity conviction. The pardon comes 37 years after Bruce (born Leonard Schneider) died from a heroin overdose at age 40. The comedian was arrested on the misdemeanor charge for performing an "obscene, indecent, immoral, and impure" show at a Manhattan nightclub (he was eventually found guilty and sentenced to four months in prison). Last May, a group of lawyers, writers, and entertainers like Robin Williams and Phyllis Diller signed a petition asking Pataki to pardon Bruce on the grounds that he simply exercised free speech rights during his performances."
reuters
nyt
"New York Governor George Pataki today granted a posthumous pardon to Lenny Bruce, wiping away the comedian's 1964 obscenity conviction. The pardon comes 37 years after Bruce (born Leonard Schneider) died from a heroin overdose at age 40. The comedian was arrested on the misdemeanor charge for performing an "obscene, indecent, immoral, and impure" show at a Manhattan nightclub (he was eventually found guilty and sentenced to four months in prison). Last May, a group of lawyers, writers, and entertainers like Robin Williams and Phyllis Diller signed a petition asking Pataki to pardon Bruce on the grounds that he simply exercised free speech rights during his performances."
reuters
nyt
13.1.04
** amnesty international: only two eu states uphold human rights
"...only two of the 15 current member states - Luxembourg and the Netherlands - could be given a clean bill of health.
Britain stands accused of "serious human rights violations" in its responses to the September 11 attacks on the United States. Abuses were being committed in the name of the "war on terror" and the fight against illegal immigration, according to the report "Human Rights Begin at Home"."
** more grief for bush's national security doctrine - strategic studies institute:
"The global war on terrorism as presently defined and conducted is strategically unfocused, promises much more than it can deliver, and threatens to dissipate US military and other resources in an endless and hopeless search for absolute security," says the study by Jeffrey Record, a visiting scholar at the Strategic Studies Institute."
[...]
"Mr Record recommends a total overhaul of the national security strategy and says it must redirect its campaign against global terror from "unrealistic to realistic war aims".
** towards 1984 - bush administration looking to classify travellers to us according to terror risk:
"The unprecedented measure would see each visitor to the United States score on a scale of three colours - green, yellow and red - based on personal details, shortly after making their flight reservation."
[...]
"In the event that a traveller is thought to have the same characteristics as a "terror suspect", "you will not be able to immediately board the flight, you are going to be talking to law enforcement and you will be given an immediate opportunity to establish an error, if you believe one exists," Hatfield said. The airline ticket will not be reimbursed by US authorities, however, he said."
** tit-for-tat - brazil continues to check id's of travellers from the us
"At present all US visitors to Brazil must be photographed and fingerprinted. The measures, which have caused long delays for travellers, are a response to similar rules recently introduced in the United States."
** the suv principle: to avoid fuel limits, turn it into a truck
"...only two of the 15 current member states - Luxembourg and the Netherlands - could be given a clean bill of health.
Britain stands accused of "serious human rights violations" in its responses to the September 11 attacks on the United States. Abuses were being committed in the name of the "war on terror" and the fight against illegal immigration, according to the report "Human Rights Begin at Home"."
** more grief for bush's national security doctrine - strategic studies institute:
"The global war on terrorism as presently defined and conducted is strategically unfocused, promises much more than it can deliver, and threatens to dissipate US military and other resources in an endless and hopeless search for absolute security," says the study by Jeffrey Record, a visiting scholar at the Strategic Studies Institute."
[...]
"Mr Record recommends a total overhaul of the national security strategy and says it must redirect its campaign against global terror from "unrealistic to realistic war aims".
** towards 1984 - bush administration looking to classify travellers to us according to terror risk:
"The unprecedented measure would see each visitor to the United States score on a scale of three colours - green, yellow and red - based on personal details, shortly after making their flight reservation."
[...]
"In the event that a traveller is thought to have the same characteristics as a "terror suspect", "you will not be able to immediately board the flight, you are going to be talking to law enforcement and you will be given an immediate opportunity to establish an error, if you believe one exists," Hatfield said. The airline ticket will not be reimbursed by US authorities, however, he said."
** tit-for-tat - brazil continues to check id's of travellers from the us
"At present all US visitors to Brazil must be photographed and fingerprinted. The measures, which have caused long delays for travellers, are a response to similar rules recently introduced in the United States."
** the suv principle: to avoid fuel limits, turn it into a truck
12.1.04
"Lebanese President Emile Lahoud has called for an international definition of terrorism, extending beyond that given to it by the United States.
"It is not enough to declare war on what one deems terrorism without giving a precise and exact definition," Lahoud said in a meeting with foreign diplomats on Monday.
He also said it was unacceptable for states to offer their own definition in the absence of an international interpretation, alluding to the United States, which has accused Lebanon of harbouring terrorists."
"It is not enough to declare war on what one deems terrorism without giving a precise and exact definition," Lahoud said in a meeting with foreign diplomats on Monday.
He also said it was unacceptable for states to offer their own definition in the absence of an international interpretation, alluding to the United States, which has accused Lebanon of harbouring terrorists."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)